
Leading coaches have reacted to Rassie Erasmus’ six-match ban, with most refusing to comment and others defending the referees.
It’s the third time that the Springboks head coach has been banned by World Rugby, and he has received little backing from his fellow coaches after his remarks about France’s 16 knee-drop tackles that went unpunished and his insinuation that it was some form of match-fixing.
SA Rugby quickly announced that they had requested a full misconduct hearing to allow Erasmus the opportunity to contextualise his comments, but that won’t be taking place this week.
Andy Farrell and Gregor Townsend side-step
He therefore won’t be in attendance at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday when South Africa tackle Ireland in the final round-robin stage of the Nations Championship.
Speaking after naming his team for the encounter, Ireland boss Andy Farrell did not entertain any questioning around Erasmus‘ ban.
“Look, you would expect me to bat that away… So, I’d rather stay away from that if you don’t mind,” he said.
The suspension has dominated the headlines ahead of this weekend’s action and was raised in just about every press conference, even the Scottish one with Gregor Townsend humorously side-stepping the questions.
“Rassie? Is he a Japanese player?” he quipped.
When asked, ‘Is this a pretty dark week for the game?’
Townsend struggled for an answer. “How am I gonna answer that one? Apart from saying no comment. Like, it’s obviously something that’s been dealt with quickly by World Rugby, so I’m not going to add anything more to that… but good try.”
Ireland v South Africa prediction: Rassie-less Springboks to blast to Dublin victory amid Farrell’s ‘bravest’ call
Steve Borthwick defends referees
England boss Steve Borthwick was measured as ever in his response to the line of questioning around Erasmus, but unlike his fellow Home Nations coaches, he offered a more robust defence of the referees.
“The first thing, as you’d expect me to say, there’s an appeal going on, so I’m not going to comment on another coach or what another coach has done; you wouldn’t expect me to,” he said ahead of England’s clash with the All Blacks.
“What I will say is that match officials have a really tough job. It’s a really challenging job. Number two, I have absolute 100 per cent confidence and faith that every match official in every game tries to do the very best they can.
“Number three, I think they deserve enormous respect. In rugby, you respect the match officials; any player I coach, we expect the same.
“In the values of our game, respect is clearly central to that. I talked about my schoolteacher and how you refer to the referee; you call the referee ‘Sir,’ and I still do now; it has been a habit for so many years, you call the referee ‘Sir’. It doesn’t mean we always agree, but you get on with it. That is what you do in rugby.”
‘F—ing mess’ pushed World Rugby v Rassie Erasmus to its ‘tipping point’ – Jim Hamilton
Fabien Galthié hits out while Eddie Jones has some sympathy
France boss Fabien Galthié, whose players were the main focus of Erasmus’ gripes, was also quite combative and defended the referees.
“As a head coach, I have a duty of conscience towards the fans, the coaches, the players, the world of rugby,” Galthié said.
“When you have the job, you are responsible for your words and your behaviour. I work hand in hand with World Rugby and the refereeing department; I try to understand how refereeing will allow us to play or not. We had two important meetings with the 12 managers and World Rugby before the competition.
“It seemed to me that everything was clear. It seems to me that decisions are made for the common good. Without referees, there is no rugby. I must take care of refereeing. Without that, I do harm to rugby, to the supporters and to the opponents. The first thing we learn is fair play.”
Galthié stated as much despite criticising the officiating of the 2023 Rugby World Cup quarter-final defeat to South Africa and accused referees of treating France like a ‘small nation’ during the Test series against the All Blacks last year.
Meanwhile, Eddie Jones did offer some support to Erasmus in his Daily Mail column, where he wrote that he understood the cause of some of the frustrations. However, he added that he ‘overstepped the mark’ with his comment around ‘match-fixing’ and would have known the consequences of those words.
Fabien Galthie follows Steve Borthwick with Ireland mind games as France boss calls for ‘fair’ officiating
“When you’re a coach, and you have a refereeing grievance, you’ve got a choice to make. You can keep quiet publicly and go through the proper channels with World Rugby. My experience tells me if you do that, you often don’t get much joy. The other option is to get into trouble!” he wrote.
He added, “Rassie was obviously frustrated, and I can understand why. He’s a very strong character. A deep thinker. Rugby needs that, but it needs respect too.”
Eddie Jones: World Rugby gives preferential treatment but Rassie ‘overstepped the mark’
Dave Rennie on the TMOs
All Blacks head coach Dave Rennie wasn’t asked about Erasmus during his press conference, but he did comment on the hip-drop and knee-drop tackle laws and the focus around it, as well as the job the TMOs have to do.
“Hip drop tackles and that sort of thing that hasn’t really been an issue for us, but uh the guys are aware of that being a focus,” he said.
“We were mainly focusing on our own discipline, ensuring that you guys are back on side and not giving the opposition multiple opportunities when they’re down in our finish zone. These things, we just got to be we got to be more disciplined to limit England’s ability to hurt us down in the finish line.”
His comments around the TMO’s job could well have been linked to Erasmus’ press conference, but there was no clear reference to the Springboks boss.
“That’s the thing with our game. We constantly bring in more things to make the game harder to referee, and I feel for the officials in some areas,” he said.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferredou can trust
“I understand the importance of it. We don’t want guys getting injured, but it’s a pretty complex game. So, a lot of knee-drop tackles felt simultaneous – just a tackle – so there’s a lot to look at, and the TMOs have got a pretty busy life at the moment, and hopefully there’s not too much TMO intervention at the weekend.”
Overall, most coaches chose to avoid the subject or defend the referees. Only Jones offered any real sympathy for Erasmus’ frustration, while still stating that he had gone too far.
AustraliaRassie ErasmusWorld Rugby




